The pros and cons of Luca Williams-Barnett starting against Ipswich

There is a growing feeling among Tottenham supporters that Luca Williams-Barnett deserves a chance from the start, and the visit of Ipswich could be the opportunity Roberto De Zerbi needs to give the teenager that opportunity.

He has looked increasingly confident when introduced from the bench, has shown he can make things happen and, judging by the reaction from the stands and online, plenty of Spurs fans are keen to see him in the starting XI.

But would starting him on Saturday be the right call?

Tottenham attacker Luca Williams-Barnett

The pros of starting Williams-Barnett

The biggest argument in his favour is confidence.

Williams-Barnett looks like a player who believes in his ability and is not afraid to show it.

Rather than simply keeping the ball moving when he comes on, he has been willing to take responsibility, run at opponents and try to make something happen.

That sort of fearless approach can be valuable for a Tottenham side that needs players willing to take the initiative.

He has also made an impact in a number of appearances off the bench.

Tottenham attacker Luca Williams-Barnett

Those contributions have helped build the case for giving him more minutes, and there is a natural argument that the next step should be a start. We have previously argued that Tottenham must show Williams-Barnett a genuine route into the first team, and these cameos are beginning to make that pathway feel more realistic.

Cameos can only tell us so much; if De Zerbi wants to find out what Williams-Barnett can offer over a longer spell, at some point he has to give him that opportunity.

The supporters’ backing is another factor. There is a real appetite to see the youngster involved, and that enthusiasm reflects the impression he has made in his limited opportunities.

A home game against Ipswich could be a good occasion to harness that excitement and give the fans another reason to get behind the team.

The cons of starting Williams-Barnett

The obvious concern is whether it might be a little too soon.

Making an impression as a substitute is one thing; being trusted to start a Premier League game brings a different level of responsibility.

Williams-Barnett is still learning, and there is a risk that placing too much expectation on his shoulders too quickly could do more harm than good.

Spurs supporters have seen how quickly excitement around an academy prospect can grow, and Marcus Edwards’ journey from teenage sensation to a career away from north London is a useful reminder that every young player needs room to develop at his own pace.

Tottenham Hotspur attacker Savio

Spurs need to develop him carefully rather than rush him simply because supporters are excited.

There is also the possibility that Sávio could be available again.

If the Brazilian is fit, De Zerbi would have a more established option to call upon in the attacking positions.

Sávio has greater experience at this level and, if ready, may offer the manager a safer choice from the first whistle while Williams-Barnett continues to build his experience.

That does not mean the youngster should be pushed down the pecking order indefinitely.

It is simply a question of timing and choosing the right moment.

There is a difference between believing a player has the potential to become a regular starter and deciding that he is ready to take on that role right now.

Verdict: Savio is a really exciting player that Spurs fans want to see in the side but Williams-Barnett deserves an opportunity and should start vs Ipswich.

Leave a Reply